
Posted: Wed Oct 10, 2007 10:01 am
Thanks again Dan & 45PSS.
I'm not sure I want a 115mm Tessar (now). Partly this was fuelled when I've reviewed my composition work in 6x9cm and realised that I could have composed tighter - perhaps 10% cropping...thus the 115mm focal length in lieu of the 105mm Ektar.
I agree that it is a little surprising to hear that a 105mm f4.5 Tessar covers 4x5. I dispensed with my surprise and surmised that this was a measurement in centimetres
The 101/4.5 Ektar vs 105mm f3.7 Ektar issue is something I've read on the internet only. I love the tonal rendition and contrast of the Ektar 105mm f3.7 and the only comparisons of the two lenses seems to privilege resolution/sharpness over other optical qualities. For me, the 105mm Ektar prints recalls the imaging qualities of Zeiss multicoated optics with its contrast and tonal range.
Equally, I don't know what I am missing since I have never seen a 101/4.5 Ektar and its prints. The 105 Ektar f3.7 is strikingly different enough from the Voigtlander Heliar 105mm f4.5, which is comparable in design however completely different in tonal rendition.
45PSS - my main thought around the 115mm Tessar's lack of inclusion in the Vade Mecum centred around whether the lens had been detached from a former bellows' camera and sold off as a separate unit, however unlikely that it might seem for a 115mm focal length to be sold as a standard.
Kind regards,
RJ
45PSS
Zeiss=1615 instances; tessar=956 instances; 115mm=19 instances, none the exact Zeiss 115mm f4.5 tessar. There are references to a 4.5 inch f4.5 Zeiss tessar and a 4.75 f4.5 Zeiss tessar.
There are 22+ pages about Carl Zeiss and the Zeiss company. Some of the relevant:
Zeiss Landmark lenses are many: Anastigmat, Protar, Protar V11a, Planar, Tessar, Sonnars, Hologon,
Topogon, Biogon(s) are examples, and there are many other "possibles". The firm has been so fertile in
producing new designs that it is a "must" for collectors, and listing the products would be a major task, still
only superficially carried out here.
Tessar Series 1c (1906) f4.5 1.5-20in.
In 1914, it was made as 3.0, 3.5, 4.75, 5.25, 6.0, 6.5, 7.0, 8.25, 10, 12, 14, 16, 20in and 16in was suggested
for 10x8, and 6in for 5x4in. There may be other sizes, as A. Adams mentions using an 8.5in Tessar in the
1920's. (Autobiography, p60).